Paul Antoine and Carina Mirabile, both hailing from Perth, entered the Married at First Sight( MAFS ) Australia 2025 experiment with a unique history. The pair had previously dated. Paul had abruptly ended things, leaving Carina feeling hurt. Their unexpected reunion at the altar was undeniably awkward. Despite this uncomfortable start, Paul and Carina embraced the experiment. They hoped this unconventional journey could help them forge a lasting connection. Their initial interactions showed promise. They seemed willing to put their past behind them.
The Wall Punch Incident and Police Involvement
Their relationship soon took a dramatic and concerning turn. The catalyst was a seemingly innocuous event. While driving, a song by rapper Quavo played. Carina casually mentioned a past encounter with the artist. This revelation triggered an intense reaction from Paul. A heated argument ensued within the confines of their apartment. The argument escalated rapidly. In a fit of anger, Paul punched a hole in their apartment wall. This violent outburst prompted serious consequences. The incident was reported to the New South Wales Police. Authorities launched an investigation into Paul’s behavior. SafeWork NSW also initiated inquiries. They focused on the safety and well-being of all participants involved in the show. This incident cast a dark shadow over their fledgling relationship.
Confrontation at the Commitment Ceremony
The experts on MAFS Australia addressed Paul’s actions at the subsequent commitment ceremony. Expert John Aiken strongly condemned his behavior. He described Paul’s actions as “toxic, inappropriate, and unacceptable.” Aiken questioned whether Paul should remain in the experiment. Paul became emotional and broke down in tears. He expressed deep remorse for his violent outburst. Despite the gravity of the situation, Carina made a surprising decision. She chose to stand by Paul. Carina stated that she was not afraid of him. She expressed her belief in his capacity for change. This decision sparked considerable debate among viewers and experts alike.
The Divisive ‘Plan B’ Task and Betrayal
Introducing the controversial ‘Plan B’ task further destabilized their fragile bond. This task aimed to test the loyalty of the couples. Participants were offered the opportunity to meet alternative matches. Paul decided to meet his ‘Plan B’ match. This decision deeply upset Carina. She viewed his choice as a profound betrayal. It raised significant red flags for her regarding their potential long-term compatibility. The ‘Plan B’ task significantly eroded Carina’s trust in Paul. It created a palpable distance between them.
Partner Swap and Lingering Past Connections
During the partner swap week, Paul was paired with Awhina Rutene. This pairing introduced an unexpected layer of complexity. Paul had a prior romantic connection with Awhina’s twin sister, Cleo. This revelation made Carina feel uneasy. Her discomfort grew when she learned that Paul had confided in Awhina. He discussed his relationship issues with Carina. He reportedly described Carina as “a bit of a snob” and “judgy.” Carina felt deeply betrayed by these private conversations. This further damaged the already strained relationship between Paul and Carina. The partner swap week proved to be a significant turning point.
Final Vows and a Heartbreaking Farewell
As the experiment approached its conclusion, Carina engaged in serious self-reflection. She considered the numerous challenges and setbacks their relationship had endured. During her final vows, Carina directly addressed the incidents severely impacting their bond. She stated that the trust between them was irreparably broken. She declared that she could not envision a future together. Despite Paul’s tearful pleas for another chance to make their relationship work, Carina made a firm decision. She chose to end their tumultuous journey. This decision left Paul visibly heartbroken and emotional.
Public Reaction and the Aftermath of a Stormy Relationship
The public’s reaction to Paul and Carina’s volatile relationship was varied. Some viewers expressed sympathy for Paul’s emotional struggles and his remorse. However, many others strongly criticized his violent behavior. Questions were also raised about the show’s decision to allow him to continue participating after the wall-punching incident. This situation ignited broader conversations—discussions centered on domestic violence and the ethical responsibilities of reality television producers. The focus was on ensuring the safety and well-being of all participants involved in such intense experiments.
As of April 2025, Paul and Carina have not reconciled their differences. Both individuals have publicly stated their intention to move forward independently. They each focus on personal growth and healing after their emotionally charged experience on MAFS Australia 2025. Their journey was a stark reminder of the complexities and potential pitfalls of relationships formed under such extraordinary circumstances.